Current:Home > ScamsSouth Carolina’s top public health doctor warns senators wrong lessons being learned from COVID -WealthRoots Academy
South Carolina’s top public health doctor warns senators wrong lessons being learned from COVID
View
Date:2025-04-15 23:00:15
COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — South Carolina’s top doctor came before a small group of state senators on Thursday to tell them he thinks a bill overhauling how public health emergencies are handled in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic has some bad ideas, concerns echoed by Gov. Henry McMaster.
As drafted, the bill would prevent mandating vaccines unless they have been licensed by the Food and Drug Administration for 10 years. That means that health care providers would be blocked from requiring flu vaccines or other shots that get yearly updates for ever-changing viruses, said Dr. Edward Simmer, director of the state Department of Health and Environmental Control.
In addition to loosening restrictions on who can visit people in isolation, the measure would also require symptom-free patients to be released from quarantine well before some infectious diseases begin to show outward signs, Simmer said at a Thursday hearing.
“There are a number of issues that we believe where this bill would cause harm to the people of South Carolina and would in fact cause unnecessary death amongst people of South Carolina during a public health crisis because it would prevent us from taking actions that could save lives,” Simmer said.
The bill passed the Senate subcommittee on a 4-3 vote, but with eight weeks to go in the General Assembly’s session, it still has to get through the body’s Medical Affairs Committee and a vote on the Senate floor before it can even be sent to the House.
In a further sign of the hurdles the bill faces, McMaster sent the subcommittee a letter saying “placing overbroad restrictions on the authority of public health officials, law enforcement officers, first responders, and emergency management professionals responding to emerging threats and disasters—whether public health or otherwise — is a bad idea.”
A similar subcommittee met in September, where many speakers sewed doubt about vaccine safety and efficacy, as well as distrust in the scientific establishment.
Members on Thursday listened to Simmer and took up some amendments on his concern and promised to discuss his other worries with the bill.
“You are making some good points, Dr. Simmer. I’m writing them all down,” Republican Sen. Richard Cash of Powdersville said.
The proposal would require health officials to release someone from quarantine if they didn’t show symptoms for five days. Simmers said people with diseases like measles, meningitis, bird flu and Ebola are contagious, but may not show symptoms for a week or more.
“I don’t think we would want after 10 days to release a person known to be infected with Ebola into the public,” Simmer said.
Supporters of the bill said they weren’t happy that during the start of the COVID-19 pandemic hospitals and nursing homes put patients into isolation. Allowing quicker releases from isolation and letting more people to visit someone in quarantine was a response to that issue.
Cash told Simmer that when the pandemic shutdown started, his wife had just endured a 17-hour cancer surgery and he was ordered to leave her bedside.
“Whatever she’s got, I got. But I still had to go,” Cash said.
Simmer said those decisions were made by the private nursing homes, hospitals and health care facilities. He said he had sympathy for decisions that had to be made quickly without much data, but he thought they were still wrong and pointed out the state didn’t order anyone to take a vaccine or isolate entire facilities.
“We saw the pictures of people seeing nursing home patients through a window. They should have been allowed in,” Simmer said. “When that didn’t happen that was a mistake. That was a lesson learned from COVID.”
Simmer asked lawmakers to pay attention to what actually happened during the pandemic and not just what they think happened.
“If this bill is designed to address concerns about COVID, we should recognize what did and did not happen during the pandemic,” Simmer said.
veryGood! (657)
Related
- Whoopi Goldberg is delightfully vile as Miss Hannigan in ‘Annie’ stage return
- Bill Clinton reflects on post-White House years in the upcoming memoir ‘Citizen’
- Customer points gun on Burger King employee after getting a discounted breakfast, police say
- The Masked Singer's Lizard Revealed as 2000s R&B Icon
- Tom Holland's New Venture Revealed
- Worker burned in explosion at Wisconsin stadium settles lawsuit for $22 million, attorney says
- Video shows Savannah Graziano shot by San Bernardino County sheriff's deputies
- Netflix docuseries on abuse allegations at New York boarding school prompts fresh investigation
- Behind on your annual reading goal? Books under 200 pages to read before 2024 ends
- Bill Clinton reflects on post-White House years in the upcoming memoir ‘Citizen’
Ranking
- How to watch new prequel series 'Dexter: Original Sin': Premiere date, cast, streaming
- What to know about the latest bird flu outbreak in the US
- Is dry shampoo bad for your hair? Here’s what you need to know.
- Caitlin Clark picks up second straight national player of the year award
- How to watch new prequel series 'Dexter: Original Sin': Premiere date, cast, streaming
- A bullet train to Sin City? What to know about Brightline West project between LA and Vegas
- LSU star Angel Reese uses Vogue photoshoot to declare for WNBA draft: I like to do everything big
- Judge refuses to delay Trump's hush money trial while Supreme Court weighs presidential immunity
Recommendation
Paula Abdul settles lawsuit with former 'So You Think You Can Dance' co
A bullet train to Sin City? What to know about Brightline West project between LA and Vegas
'Call Her Daddy' star Alex Cooper joins NBC's 2024 Paris Olympics coverage
UConn men's team arrives in Phoenix after flight to Final Four delayed by plane issues
Who are the most valuable sports franchises? Forbes releases new list of top 50 teams
Tom Felton Reveals Which Scene He Wishes Made It Into Harry Potter
Tiger Woods' ankle has 'zero mobility,' Notah Begay says before the Masters
Experienced climber found dead in Mount St. Helens volcano crater 1,200 feet below summit